Question from the peanut gallery: How did monks purge their vessels? "Purging" the air from a carboy seems a logical thing to do but really, how much effect will it have? I've never purged a carboy and never had anything I can identify as oxidation in my beers. Yes, there is surface area exposed to oxygen but what is the uptake rate? The fermenting (or fermented) beer has CO2 dissolved in it, CO2 is heavier than air so no matter what you do, there will be a protective layer of gas over the beer. This business of purging seems to be an excess of caution to me. I'll grant my next beer may come out tasting of stale cardboard but I'm betting if I don't shake up the carboy after fermentation, I'll be just fine. I may sacrifice a few weeks of shelf life but guess what, I'll never know! No way to do the experiment to determine the effect of the treatment unless I split several batches into 3-gal carboys, purged one of the two and taste-tested several months later. If you think or can prove that purging extends shelf life or prevents cold-side oxidation, great; otherwise, always ask why, and what is the effect.