- Joined
- Jul 16, 2012
- Messages
- 10,254
- Reaction score
- 8,365
- Points
- 113
Wine fermentations and beer fermentations are different things. In a wine fermentation, you want to stress the yeast - when we first started doing wine, I was amazed that we were pitching 7 grams of yeast into 6 gallons of must at 1.090 or greater - that's a vast underpitch by beer standards! We weren't oxygenating, either, another no-no for beer fermentations. Then I realized most of the flavors in wine result from stressed yeast, esters and so forth. Fast forward to beer: With beer, you want a healthy pitch of yeast so that when they run out of sugars to digest, enough are still viable and hungry to clean up the fermentation by-products. Lessening the lag time is not so important - I've had good fermentations that didn't kick off until 36 hours after pitch. For beers, it's important to have enough healthy yeast at the end of the fermentation to clean up after themselves, hence the heed for a much higher pitch rate. Also, wine yeast are largely living off glucose, easy for them to digest. Beer yeast largely live off maltose, requiring a bit more energy from the cell to metabolize.Yeast are living funi that bud (break apart from 1ea to 2ea) as they multiply. Small yeast count will eventually make no difference as they have to reach a certain population when the real alcoholic fermentation begins. During the "build up" period there is little alcohol aka EtOH produced as they are using available oxygen for growth. When the oxygen available in the beverage is used up their conversion to EtOH then begins in real earnest. The reason for a starter or a large amount of dry yeast addition is to lessen the "lag" time from the addition to the beginning of some real fermentation that produces the CO2. EtOH is also produced in similar quantities to CO2.
At the winery we add 1 lb / thousand gallons 1lb/M and have done that for years and have great success with fermentation. Key with wine and yeast is to not add it below 53 degrees as they have little growth (cold) at that temp and takes quite a while to start doing some serious reproductions. It is the enzymes that are produced in the splitting of the yeast cell that starts the chain reactions to producing alcohol. The sugar molecule has an oxygen molecule attached and they are after that along with the minute carbohydrate they use for growing. We have some yeast, like Uvaferm 43 that have a large temperature range for fermentation, and can work optimally even up to 95 deg F. We use that almost exclusively for our red wines and use it for Icewine as well since it is a powerful fermenting yeast. Each wine yeast has a temperature range that is optimal for it. So I guess it is also with beer yeasts that come are better adapted to handling the higher temperature of fermentation than others. I have it written down at work what some of the more common yeasts we use temperature ranges are, if anyone is interested.
In a sense, you're right. All it really takes is one cell and time. But by adding a lot of cells, more than you as a winemaker think you need, you get much better beer. Temperature makes a difference: I participated in that experiment and could tell a difference between the two; however, I haven't had a chance to ask if the Brulosophy guys fermented monitoring the temperature in the fermentation or in the surrounding ambient air. I know and respect the Brulosophy guys but I'm not willing to throw out hundreds of years of brewing knowledge based on one test, particularly when the conditions aren't as controlled as in a big brewery.